DIRECTLY that your worldly friends perceive that you aim at leading a devout
life, they will let loose endless shafts of mockery
and misrepresentation upon you; the more malicious will attribute your change to hypocrisy,
designing, or bigotry; they will affirm that the
world having looked coldly upon you, failing its
favour you turn to God; while your friends will
make a series of what, from their point of view,
are prudent and charitable remonstrances. They
will tell you that you are growing morbid; that
you will lose your worldly credit, and will make
yourself unacceptable to the world; they will
prognosticate your premature old age, the ruin
My daughter, all this is vain and foolish talk: these people have no real regard either for your bodily health or your material prosperity. " If ye were of the world," the Saviour has said, "the world would love his own; but because ye are not of the world, but I have chosen you out of the world, therefore the world hateth you." 1
We have all seen men, and women too, pass the whole night, even several in succession, playing at chess or cards; and what can be a more dismal, unwholesome thing than that? But the world has not a word to say against it, and their friends are nowise troubled. But give up an hour to meditation, or get up rather earlier than usual to prepare for Holy Communion, and they will send for the doctor to cure you of hypochondria or jaundice ! People spend every night for a month dancing, and no one will complain of being the worse; but if they keep the one watch of Christmas Eve, we shall hear of endless colds and maladies the next day ! Is it not as plain as possible that the world is an unjust judge; indulgent and kindly to its own children, harsh and uncharitable to the children of God?
We cannot stand well with the world save by renouncing His approval. It is not possible to satisfy the world's unreasonable demands: "John the Baptist came neither eating bread nor drinking wine; and ye say he hath a devil. The Son of Man is come eating and drinking, and ye say, Behold a gluttonous man, and a winebibber, the friend of publicans and sinners." 1 Even so, my child, if we give in to the world, and laugh, dance, and play as it does, it will affect to be scandalized; if we refuse to do so, it will accuse us of being hypocritical or morbid. If we adorn ourselves after its fashion, it will put some evil construction on what we do; if we go in plain attire, it will accuse us of meanness; our cheerfulness will be called dissipation; our mortification dulness; and ever casting its evil eye upon us, nothing we can do will please it. It exaggerates our failings, and publishes them abroad as sins; it represents our venial sins as mortal, and our sins of infirmity as malicious. S. Paul says that charity is kind, but the world is unkind; charity thinks no evil, but the world thinks evil of every one, and if it cannot find fault with our actions, it is sure at least to impute bad motives to them,--whether the sheep be black or white, horned or no, the wolf will devour them if he can.
Do what we will, the world must wage war upon us. If we spend any length of time in confession, it will speculate on what we have so much to say about ! if we are brief, it will suggest that we are keeping back something ! It spies out our every act, and at the most trifling angry word, sets us down as intolerable. Attention to business is avarice, meekness mere silliness; whereas the wrath of worldly people is to be reckoned as generosity, their avarice, economy, their mean deeds, honourable. There are always spiders at hand to spoil the honey-bee's comb.
Let us leave the blind world to make as much noise as it may,--like a bat molesting the songbirds of day; let us be firm in our ways, unchangeable in our resolutions, and perseverance will be the test of our self-surrender to God, and our deliberate choice of the devout life.
The planets and a wandering comet shine
with much the same brightness, but the comet's
is a passing blaze, which does not linger long,
while the planets cease not to display their
brightness. Even so hypocrisy and real goodness have much outward resemblance; but one
is easily known from the other, inasmuch as
hypocrisy is short-lived, and disperses like a
mist, while real goodness is firm and abiding.
There is no surer groundwork for the beginnings
of a devout life than the endurance of misrepre
HOWEVER much we may admire and
crave for light, it is apt to dazzle our
eyes when they have been long accustomed to
darkness; and on first visiting a foreign country,
we are sure to feel strange among its inhabitants,
however kindly or courteous they may be. Even
so, my child, your changed life may be attended
with some inward discomfort, and you may feel
some reaction of discouragement and weariness
after you have taken a final farewell of the world
and its follies. Should it be so, I pray you take
it patiently, for it will not last,--it is merely the
disturbance caused by novelty; and when it is
gone by, you will abound in consolations. At
first you may suffer somewhat under the loss
what you enjoyed among your vain, frivolous
But you see before you the mountain of Christian perfection, which is very high, and you
exclaim in fearfulness that you can never ascend
it. Be of good cheer, my child. When the young
bees first begin to live they are mere grubs, unable
to hover over flowers, or to fly to the mountains,
or even to the little hills where they might gather
honey; but they are fed for a time with the
honey laid up by their predecessors, and by
degrees the grubs put forth their wings and grow
strong, until they fly abroad and gather their
harvest from all the country round. Now we
are yet but as grubs in devotion, unable to fly at
will, and attain the desired aim of Christian perfection; but if we begin to take shape through
PICTURE to yourself a young princess beloved of her husband, to whom some evil
wretch should send a messenger to tempt her to
infidelity. First, the messenger would bring forth
his propositions. Secondly, the princess would
either accept or reject the overtures. Thirdly,
she would consent to them or refuse them. Even
so, when Satan, the world, and the flesh look
upon a soul espoused to the Son of God, they
set temptations and suggestions before that soul,
whereby--1. Sin is proposed to it. 2. Which
proposals are either pleasing or displeasing to
the soul. 3. The soul either consents, or
rejects them. In other words, the three down
If we should undergo the temptation to every sin whatsoever during our whole life, that would not damage us in the Sight of God's Majesty, provided we took no pleasure in it, and did not consent to it; and that because in temptation we do not act, we only suffer, and inasmuch as we take no delight in it, we can be liable to no blame. S. Paul bore long time with temptations of the flesh, but so far from displeasing God thereby, He was glorified in them. The blessed Angela di Foligni underwent terrible carnal temptations, which move us to pity as we read of them. S. Francis and S. Benedict both experienced grievous temptations, so that the one cast himself amid thorns, the other into the snow, to quench them, but so far from losing anything of God's Grace thereby, they greatly increased it.
Be then very courageous amid temptation, and never imagine yourself conquered so long as it is displeasing to you, ever bearing in mind the difference between experiencing and consenting to temptation, 1 --that difference being,
But again, as to the pleasure which may be
taken in temptation (technically called delectation), inasmuch as our souls have two parts, one
inferior, the other superior, and the inferior does
not always choose to be led by the superior, but
Have you ever watched a great burning furnace heaped up with ashes? Look at it some ten or twelve hours afterwards, and there will scarce be any living fire there, or only a little smouldering in the very heart thereof. Nevertheless, if you can find that tiny lingering spark, it will suffice to rekindle the extinguished flames. So it is with love, which is the true spiritual life amid our greatest, most active temptations. Temptation, flinging its delectation into the inferior part of the soul, covers it wholly with ashes, and leaves but a little spark of God's Love, which can be found nowhere save hidden far down in the heart or mind, and even that is hard to find. But nevertheless it is there, since however troubled we may have been in body and mind, we firmly resolved not to consent to sin or the temptation thereto, and that delectation of the exterior man was rejected by the interior spirit. Thus though our will may have been thoroughly
THIS distinction, which is very important, is well illustrated by the description S. Jerome gives of a young man bound to a voluptuous bed by the softest silken cords, and subjected to the wiles and lures of a treacherous tempter, with the express object of causing him to fall.. Greatly as all his senses and imagination must inevitably have been possessed by so vehement an assault, he proved that his heart was free and his will unconquered, for, having physical control over no member save his tongue, he bit that off and spat it out at his foe, a foe more terrible than the tyrant's executioners.
S. Catherine of Sienna has left a somewhat
similar record. The Evil One having obtained
permission from God to assault that pious virgin
with all his strength, so long as he laid no hand
upon her, filled her heart with impure suggestions, and surrounded her with every conceivable
temptation of sight and sound, which, pene
Here, you see, were the embers covered over with ashes, while temptation and delectation had entered the heart and surrounded the will, which, aided only by the Saviour, resisted all evil inspirations with great disgust, and a persevering refusal to consent to sin. Verily the soul which loves God is sometimes in sore straits to know whether He abideth in it or no, and whether that Divine Love for which it fights is extinguished or burns yet. But it is the very essence of the perfection of that Heavenly Love to require its lovers to endure and fight for Love's sake, without knowing even whether they possess the very Love for which and in which they strive.
GOD never permits such grievous temptations and assaults to try any, save those
souls whom He designs to lead on to His own
living, highest love, but nevertheless it does
not follow as a natural consequence that they
Come what may in the shape of temptation,
attended by whatsoever of delectation,--so long
as your will refuses consent, not merely to the
temptation itself, but also to the delectation, you
need have no fear,--God is not offended. When
any one has swooned away, and gives no sign of
life, we put our hand to his heart, and if we find
the slightest fluttering there, we conclude that he
still lives, and that, with the help of stimulants
and counter-irritants, we may restore consciousness and power. Even so, sometimes amid the
violence of temptation the soul seems altogether
to faint away, and to lose all spiritual life and
action. But if you would be sure how it really
When Temptation and Delectation are Sin.
THAT princess, whom we have already
taken as an illustration, was not to blame
in the unlawful pursuit we supposed to be made
of her, because it was against her will; but if,
on the contrary, she had in any way led to it, or
sought to attract him who sought her, she were
certainly guilty of the pursuit itself; and even if
she withheld her consent, she would still deserve
censure and punishment. Thus it sometimes
happens that temptation in itself is sin to us,
When it is possible to avoid the delectation arising out of temptation, it is always a sin to accept it, in proportion to the pleasure we take. and the amount of consent given, whether that be great or small, brief or lasting. The princess of our illustration is to blame if she merely listens to the guilty propositions made to her but still more so if, after listening, she takes pleasure in them, and allows her heart to feed and rest thereupon; for although she has no intention of really doing that which is proposed, her heart gives a spiritual consent when she takes pleasure in it, and it must always be wrong to let either body or mind rest on anything unworthy,--and wrongdoing lies so entirely in the heart's co-operation, that without this no mere bodily action can be sin.
Therefore, when you are tempted to any sin, 30 6 examine whether you voluntarily exposed yourself to the temptation, and if you find that you have done so by putting yourself into its way, or by not foreseeing the temptation, as you ought to have done, then it is sin; but if you have done nothing to bring about the temptation, it is not in anywise to be imputed to you as sin.
When the delectation which attends temptation might have been avoided, but has not been
avoided, there is always a certain amount of sin
according to the degree to which we have
lingered over it, and the kind of pleasure we
have taken in it. If a woman who has not
wilfully attracted unlawful admiration, nevertheless takes pleasure in such admiration, she is
doing wrong, always supposing that what pleases
her is the admiration. But if the person who
courts her plays exquisitely on the lute, and she
took pleasure, not in the personal attentions paid
to herself, but in the sweetness and harmony of
the music, there would be no sin in that, although
it would be wrong to give way to any extent to
her pleasure, for fear of its leading on to pleasure in the pursuit of herself. So again, if some
clever stratagem whereby to avenge me of an
enemy is suggested, and I take no satisfaction
and give no consent to the vengeance, but nun
only pleased at the cleverness of the invention,
I am not sinning; although it were very inex
Sometimes we are taken by surprise by some sense of delectation following so closely upon the temptation, that we are off our guard. This can be but a very slight venial sin, which would become greater if, after once we perceive the danger, we allow ourselves to dally with it, or question as to admitting or rejecting it,--greater still if we carelessly neglect to resist it;--and if we deliberately allow ourselves to rest in any such pleasure, it becomes very great sin, especially if the thing attracting us be unquestionably evil. Thus it is a great sin in a woman to allow herself to dwell upon any unlawful affections, although she may have no intention of ever really yielding to them.
SO soon as you feel yourself anywise tempted,
do as our little children when they see a
wolf or a bear in the mountains. Forthwith
they run to the protection of their father or
mother, or at least cry out for help. Do you
If, nevertheless, the temptation persists or increases, hasten -in spirit to embrace the holy Cross, as though you beheld Jesus Christ Crucified actually Present. Make firm protests against consenting, and ask His Help thereto; and, so long as the temptation lasts, do you persist in making acts of non-consent. But while making these acts and these protests, do not fix your eyes on the temptation,--look solely on Our Lord, for if you dwell on the temptation, especially when it is strong, your courage may be shaken. Divert your mind with any right and healthy occupation, for if that takes possession and fills your thoughts, it will drive away temptation and evil imaginations.
One great remedy against all manner of temptation, great or small, is to open the heart and lay bare its suggestions, likings, and dislikings, to your director; for, as you may observe, the first condition which the Evil One makes with a soul, when he wants to seduce it, is silence. Even as a bad man, seeking to seduce a woman, enjoins silence concerning himself to her father or husband, whereas God would always have
If, after all, the temptation still troubles and persecutes us, there is nothing to be done on our side save to persist in protesting that we will not consent; for just as no maiden can be married while she persists in saying No, so no soul, however oppressed, can be guilty while it says the same.
Do not argue with your Enemy, and give but one answer,--that with which Our Lord confounded him, "Get thee hence, Satan, for it is written, Thou shalt worship the Lord thy God, and Him only shalt thou serve." 1 Just as the pure wife would make no reply, and cast no glance on the foul seducer who strove to lead her astray, but would straightway fly from him to her husband's side, not arguing, but cleaving to her lawful lord in renewed fidelity;--so the devout soul when assailed by temptation should never trifle with it by answer or argument, but simply fly to the Side of Jesus Christ, its Bridegroom; renewing its pledges of unchanging devotion and faithfulness to Him.
WHILE it is right to resist great temptations with invincible courage, and all
such victories will be most valuable, still there is
perhaps more absolute profit to our souls in resisting little ones. For although the greater
temptations exceed in power, there are so infinitely more in number of-little temptations, that
a victory over them is fully as important as over
the greater but rarer ones. No one will question
but that wolves and bears are more dangerous
than flies, but they do not worry and annoy us, or
try our patience as these do. WHIt is not a hard
thing to abstain from murder, but it is very difficult to avoid all passing fits of anger, which assail
us at every moment. A man or woman can
easily keep from adultery, but it is less easy to
abstain from all words and glances which are disloyal. WHIt is easy to keep from stealing another
man's goods, but often difficult to resist coveting them; easy to avoid bearing false witness in
direct judgment, difficult to be perfectly truthful
in conversation; easy to refrain from getting
drunk, difficult to be absolutely sober; easy not
to wish for a neighbour's death, difficult not to
WHIn short, all these minor temptations to anger, suspicion, jealousy, envy, levity, vanity, duplicity, affectation, foolish thoughts, and the like, are a perpetual trial even to those who are most devout and most resolute; and therefore, my daughter, we onght carefully and diligently to prepare for this warfare. Be assured that every victory won over these little foes is as a precious stone in the crown of glory which God prepares for us in Paradise. So, while awaiting and making ready for a stedfast and brave resistance to great temptations should they come, let us not fail diligently to fight against these meaner, weaker foes.
NOW as to all these trifling temptations of
vanity, suspicion, vexation, jealousy, envy,
and the like, which flit around one like flies or
gnats, now settling on one's nose,--anon stinging
one's cheek,--as it is wholly impossible altogether to free one's-self from their importunity;
the best resistance one can make is not to be
fretted by them. All these things may worry
Therefore despise all these trivial onslaughts,
and do not even deign to think about them; but
let them buzz about your ears as much as they
please, and flit hither and thither just as you tolerate flies;--even if they sting you, and strive
to light within your heart, do no more than
simply remove them, not fighting with them, or
arguing, but simply doing that which is precisely
contrary to their suggestions, and specially
making acts of the Love of God. WHIf you will
take my advice, you will not toil on obstinately
in resisting them by exercising the contrary
virtue, for that would become a sort of struggle
with the foe;--but, after making an act of this
directly contrary virtue (always supposing you
have time to recognise what the definite temptation is), simply turn with your whole heart
towards Jesus Christ Crucified, and lovingly kiss
His Sacred Feet. This is the best way to conquer the Enemy, whether in small or great
temptations; for inasmuch as the Love of God
contains the perfection of every virtue, and that
more excellently than the very virtues themselves;
it is also the most sovereign remedy against all
vice, and if you accustom your mind under all
manner of temptation to have recourse to this
safety-place, you will not be constrained to enter
In short, you may be sure that if you daily with your minor, oft-recurring temptations, and examine too closely into them in detail, you will simply stupefy yourself to no purpose.
EXAMINE from time to time what are the
dominant passions of your soul, and having ascertained this, mould your life, so that in
thought, word and deed you may as far as possible
counteract them. For instance, if you know
that you are disposed to be vain, reflect often upon
the emptiness of this earthly life, call to mind how
burdensome all mere earthly vanities will be
to the conscience at the hour of death, how
unworthy of a generous heart, how puerile and
childish, and the like. See that your words
In a word, let your time of peace,--that is to say, the time when you are not beset by temptations to sin,--be used in cultivating the graces most opposed to your natural difficulties, and if opportunities for their exercise do not arise, go out of your way to seek them, and by so doing you will strengthen your heart against future temptations.
ANXIETY of mind is not so much an
abstract temptation, as the source whence
various temptations arise. Sadness, when defined, is the mental grief we feel because of our
involuntary ailments;---whether the evil be
exterior, such as poverty, sickness or contempt;
or interior, such as ignorance, dryness, depression or temptation. Directly that the soul is
conscious of some such trouble, it is downcast,
and so trouble sets in. Then we at once begin
to try to get rid of it, and find means to shake it
off; and so far rightly enough, for it is natural
If any one strives to be delivered from his troubles out of love of God, he will strive patiently, gently, humbly and calmly, looking for deliverance rather to God's Goodness and Providence than to his own industry or efforts; but if self-love is the prevailing object he will grow hot and eager in seeking relief, as though all depended more upon himself than upon God. I do not say that the person thinks so, but he acts eagerly as though he did think it. Then if he does not find what he wants at once, he becomes exceedingly impatient and troubled, which does not mend matters, but on the contrary makes them worse, and so he gets into an unreasonable state of anxiety and distress, till he begins to fancy that there is no cure for his trouble. Thus you see how a disturbance, which was right at the outset, begets anxiety, and anxiety goes on into an excessive distress, which is exceedingly dangerous.
This unresting anxiety is the greatest evil
which can happen to the soul, sin only excepted.
Just as internal commotions and seditions
ruin a commonwealth, and make it incapable of
resisting its foreign enemies, so if our heart be
disturbed and anxious, it loses power to retain
such graces as it has, as well as strength to resist
Anxiety arises from an unregulated desire to be delivered from any pressing evil, or to obtain some hoped-for good. Nevertheless nothing tends so greatly to enchance the one or retard the other as over-eagerness and anxiety. Birds that are captured in nets and snares become inextricably entangled therein, because they flutter and struggle so much. Therefore, whensoever you urgently desire to be delivered from any evil, or to attain some good thing, strive above all else to keep a calm, restful spirit,--steady your judgment and will, and then go quietly and easily after your object, taking all fitting means to attain thereto. By easily I do not mean carelessly, but without eagerness, disquietude or anxiety; otherwise, so far from bringing about what you wish, you will hinder it, and add more and more to your perplexities. "My soul is alway in my hand, yet do I not forget Thy Law," 1 David says. Examine yourself often, at least night and morning, as to whether your soul is "in your hand;" or whether it has been wrested thence by any passionate or anxious emotion. See whether your soul is fully under control, or whether it has not in anywise escaped
Do not allow any wishes to disturb your mind under the pretext of their being trifling and unimportant; for if they gain the day, greater and weightier matters will find your heart more accessible to disturbance. When you are conscious that you are growing anxious, commend yourself to God, and resolve stedfastly not to take any steps whatever to obtain the result you desire, until your disturbed state of mind is altogether quieted;--unless indeed it should be necessary to do something without delay, in which case you must restrain the rush of inclination, moderating it, as far as possible, so as to act rather from reason than impulse.
If you can lay your anxiety before your spiritual guide, or at least before some trusty and
devout friend, you may be sure that you will find
great solace. The heart finds relief in telling its
says that "godly sorrow worketh reS. PAUL
pentance to salvation not to be repented of, but the sorrow of the world worketh death."' So we see that sorrow may be good or bad according to the several results it produces in us. And indeed there are more bad than good results arising from it, for the only good ones are mercy and repentance; whereas there are six evil results, namely, anguish, sloth, indignation, jealousy, envy and impatience. The Wise Man says that " sorrow hath killed many, and there is no profit therein," 2 and that because for the two good
The Enemy makes use of sadness to try good men with his temptations:--just as he tries to make bad men merry in their sin, so he seeks to make the good sorrowful amid their works of piety; and while making sin attractive so as to draw men to it, he strives to turn them from holiness by making it disagreeable. The Evil One delights in sadness and melancholy, because they are his own characteristics. He will be in sadness and sorrow through all Eternity, and he would fain have all others the same.
The " sorrow of the world" disturbs the heart, plunges it into anxiety, stirs up unreasonable fears, disgusts it with prayer, overwhelms and stupefies the brain, deprives the soul of wisdom, judgment, resolution and courage, weakening all its powers; in a word, it is like a hard winter, blasting all the earth's beauty, and numbing all animal life; for it deprives the soul of sweetness and power in every faculty.
Should you, my daughter, ever be attacked by by this evil spirit of sadness, make use of the following remedies. "Is any among you afflicted ?" says S. James, "let him pray." 1 Prayer is a sovereign remedy, it lifts the mind to God, Who is our only Joy and Consolation. But when
Vigorously resist all tendencies to melancholy, and although all you do may seem to be done coldly, wearily and indifferently, do not give in. The Enemy strives to make us languid in doing good by depression, but when he sees that we do not cease our efforts to work, and that those efforts become all the more earnest by reason of their being made in resistance to him, he leaves off troubling us.
Make use of hymns and spiritual songs; they
have often frustrated the Evil One in his operations, as was the case when the evil spirit which
possessed Saul was driven forth by music and
psalmody. It is well also to occupy yourself in
external works, and that with as much variety as
may lead us to divert the mind from the subject which oppresses it, and to cheer and kindle
it, for depression generally makes us dry and
cold. Use external acts of fervour, even though
they are tasteless at the time; embrace your
crucifix, clasp it to your breast, kiss the Feet and
Hands of your Dear Lord, raise hands and eyes
to Heaven, and cry out to God in loving, trustful
ejaculations: "My Beloved is mine, and I am
Moderate bodily discipline is useful in resisting depression, because it rouses the mind from dwelling on itself; and frequent Communion is specially valuable; the Bread of Life strengthens the heart and gladdens the spirits.
Lay bare all the feelings, thoughts and longings which are the result of your depression to your confessor or director, in all humility and faithfulness; seek the society of spirituallyminded people, and frequent such as far as possible while you are suffering. And, finally, resign yourself into God's Hands, endeavouring to bear this harassing depression patiently, as a just punishment for past idle mirth. Above all, never doubt but that, after He has tried you sufficiently, God will deliver you from the trial.
THE order of God's Providence maintains a perpetual vicissitude in the material being of this world; day is continually turning to night, spring to summer, summer to autumn autumn to winter, winter to spring; no two days are ever exactly alike. Some are foggy, rainy, some dry or windy; and this endless variety greatly enhances the beauty of the universe. And even so precisely is it with man (who, as ancient writers have said, is a miniature of the world), for he is never long in any one condition, and his life on earth flows by like the mighty waters, heaving and tossing with an endless variety of motion; one while raising him on high with hope, another plunging him low in fear; now turning him to the right with rejoicing, then driving him to the left with sorrows; and no single day, no, not even one hour, is entirely the same as any other of his life.
All this is a very weighty warning, and teaches
us to aim at an abiding and unchangeable evenness of mind amid so great an uncertainty of
events; and, while all around is changing, we
But let us come to some special detail, beyond this general doctrine.
1. I would say, then, that devotion does not consist in conscious sweetness and tender consolations, which move one to sighs and tears, and bring about a kind of agreeable, acceptable sense of self-satisfaction. No, my child, this is not one and the same as devotion, for you will find many persons who do experience these consolations, yet who, nevertheless, are evilminded, and consequently are devoid of all true Love of God, still more of all true devotion. When Saul was in pursuit of Dayid, who fled from him into the wilderness of En-gedi, he entered into a cave alone, wherein David and his
2. Nevertheless these tender warm emotions are sometimes good and useful, for they kindle the spiritual appetite, cheer the mind, and infuse a holy gladness into the devout life,- which embellishes all we do even externally. It was such a taste for holy things that made David cry out, " 0 how sweet are Thy words unto my throat, yea, sweeter than honey unto my mouth." 1 And assuredly the tiniest little comfort received through devotion is worth far more than the most abundant delights of this world. The milk of the Heavenly Bridegroom, in other words His spiritual favours, are sweeter to the soul than the costliest wine of the pleasures of this world, and to those who have tasted thereof all else seems but as gall and wormwood. There is a certain herb which, if chewed, imparts so great a sweetness that they who keep it in their mouth cannot hunger or thirst; even so those to whom God gives His Heavenly manna of
3. But, perhaps you will say, if there are
sensible consolations which are undoubtedly
good and come from God, and at the same time
others which are unprofitable, perilous, even
harmful, because they proceed from mere natural
causes, or even from the Enemy himself, how
am I to know one from the other, or distinguish
what is most profitable even among those which
are good? It is a general rule, with respect to
the feelings and affections, that their test is in
their fruits. Our hearts are as trees, of which
the affections and passions are their branches,
4. If we are favoured with any such sweetness,
we must humble ourselves deeply before God,
and heware of being led to cry out "How good
I am !" No indeed, such gifts do not make us
any better, for, as I have already said, devotion
does not consist in such things; rather let us
say, "How good God is to those who hope in
Him, and to the souls that seek Him !" If a
man has sugar in his mouth, he cannot call his
Lastly, I advise you to take counsel with your director concerning any unusual flow of consolations or emotions, so that he may guide you in their wise usage; for it is written, " Hast thou found honey? eat so much as is sufficient for thee." 1
SO much for what is to be done in times of spiritual consolations. But these bright days will not last for ever, and sometimes you will be so devoid of all devout feelings,- that it will seem to you that your soul is a desert land, fruitless, sterile, wherein you can find no path leading to God, no drop of the waters of Grace to soften the dryness which threatens to choke it entirely. Verily, at such a time the soul is greatly to be pitied, above all,- when this trouble presses heavily, for then, like David,- its meat are tears day and night, while the Enemy strives to drive it to despair, crying out, "Where is now thy God? how thinkest thou to find Him, or how wilt thou ever find again the joy of His Holy Grace?"
What will you do then, my child? Look
well whence the trial comes, for we are often ourselves the cause of our own dryness and barrenness. A mother refuses sugar to her sickly child,
and so God deprives us of consolations when
they do but feed self-complacency or presumption. " It is good for me that I have been in
Again, any duplicity or unreality in confession or spiritual intercourse with your director tends to dryness and barrenness, for, if you lie to God's Holy Spirit, you can scarcely wonder that He refuses you His comfort. If you do not choose
Or you have satiated yourself with worldly delights; and so no wonder that spiritual pleasures are repulsive to you. "To the overfed dove even cherries are bitter," says an old proverb; and Our Lady in her song of praise says, " He has filled the hungry with good things, and the rich He hath sent empty away." They who abound in earthly pleasures are incapable of appreciating such as are spiritual.
If you have carefully stored up the fruits of
past consolations, you will receive more; "to
him that hath yet more shall be given," but
from him who has not kept that which he had,
who has lost it through carelessness, that which
he hath shall be taken away, in other words, he
will not receive the grace destined for him.
Rain refreshes living plants, but it only brings
rottenness and decay to those which are already
dead. There are many such causes whereby
we lose the consolations of religion, and fall into
dryness and deadness of spirit, so that it is well
to examine our conscience, and see if we can
trace any of these or similar faults. But always
remember that this examination must not be
made anxiously, or in an over-exacting spirit.
Thus if, after an honest investigation of our own
conduct, we find the cause of our wrongdoing,
1. Humble yourself profoundly before God, acknowledging your nothingness and misery. Alas, what am I when left to myself ! no better, Lord, than a parched ground, whose cracks and crevices on every side testify its need of the gracious rain of Heaven, while, nevertheless, the world's blasts wither it more and more to dust.
2. Call upon God, and ask for His Gladness. "O give me the comfort of Thy help again! My Father, if it be possible, let this cup pass from me." " Depart, O ye unfruitful wind, which parcheth up my soul, and come, O gracious south wind, blow upon my garden." Such loving desires will fill you with the perfume of holiness.
3. Go to your confessor, open your heart
thoroughly, let him see every corner of your
soul, and take all his advice with the utmost
simplicity and humility, for God loves obedience,
and He often makes the counsel we take, specially that of the guides of souls, to be more useful than would seem likely; just as He caused
the waters of Jordan, commended by Elijah to
4. But, after all, nothing is so useful, so fruitful amid this dryness and barrenness, as not to
yield to a passionate desire of being delivered
from it. I do not say that one may not desire
to be set free, but only that one ought not to
desire it over-eagerly, but to leave all to the sole
Mercy of God's special Providence, in order
that, so long as He pleases, He may keep us
amid these thorns and longings. Let us say to
God at such seasons, "O my Father, if it be
possible, let this cup pass from me; "--but let
us add heartily, " Nevertheless, not my will, but
Thine be done," and there let us abide as
trustingly as we are able. When God sees us
to be filled with such pious indifference, He will
comfort us with His grace and favour, as when
He. beheld Abraham ready to offer up his son
Isaac, and comforted him with His blessing.
In every sort of affliction, then, whether bodily
or spiritual, in every manner of distraction or loss
of sensible devotion, let us say with our whole
heart, and in the deepest submission, "The Lord
gave me all my blessings, the Lord taketh them
away, blessed be the Name of the Lord." If we
persevere in this humility, He will restore to us
His mercies as he did to Job, who ever spake
thus amid all his troubles.
5. And lastly, my daughter, amid all our dryness let us never grow discouraged, but go steadily on, patiently waiting the return of better things; let us never be misled to give up any devout practices because of it, but rather if possible, let us increase our good works, and if we cannot offer liquid preserves to our Bridegroom, let us at least offer Him dried fruit--it is all one to Him, so long as the heart we offer be fully resolved to love Him. In fine weather bees make more honey and breed fewer grubs, because they spend so much time in gathering the sweet juices of the flowers that they neglect the multiplication of their race. But in a cold, cloudy spring they have a fuller hive and less honey. And so sometimes, my daughter, in the glowing springtide of spiritual consolations, the soul spends so much time in storing them up, that amid such abundance it performs fewer good works; while, on the contrary, when amid spiritual dryness and bitterness, and devoid of all that is attractive in devotion, it multiplies its substantial good works, and abounds in the hidden virtues of patience, humility, self-abnegation, resignation and unselfishness.
Some people, especially women, fall into the
great mistake of imagining that when we offer
a dry, distasteful service to God, devoid of all
sentiment and emotion, it is unacceptable to His
A child is easily moved to fondle its mother when she gives it sweet things, but if he kisses her in return for wormwood or camomile it is a proof of very real affection on his part.
LET me illustrate what I have said by an anecdote of Saint Bernard.
It is common to most beginners in God's Service, being as yet inexperienced in the fluctuations of grace and in spiritual vicissitudes, that
when they lose the glow of sensible devotion,
and the first fascinating lights which led them in
their first steps towards God, they lose heart,
and fall into depression and discouragement.
Those who are practised in the matter say that
it is because our human nature cannot bear a prolonged deprivation of some kind of satisfaction,
either celestial or earthly; and so as souls, which
have been raised beyond their natural level by
a taste of superior joys, readily renounce visible
delights when the higher joys are taken away,
as well as those more earthly pleasures, they,
not being yet trained to a patient waiting for
the true sunshine, fancy that there is no light
Just so it fell out with a certain Geoffroy de Peronne, a member of S. Bernard's community, newly dedicated to God's Service, during a journey which he and some others were making. He became suddenly dry, deprived of all consolations, and amid his interior darkness he began to think of the friends and relations he had parted from, and of his worldly pursuits and interests, until the temptation grew so urgent that his outward aspect betrayed it, and one of those most in his confidence perceiving that he was sorely troubled, accosted him tenderly, asking him secretly, "What means this, Geoffroy? and what makes thee, contrary to thy wont, so pensive and sad ?" Whereupon Geoffroy, sighing heavily, made answer, "Woe is me, my brother, never again in my life shall I be glad !"
The other was moved to pity by these words,
and in his fraternal love he hastened to tell it all
to their common father S. Bernard, and he, realising the danger, went into the nearest church to pray
for Geoffroy, who meanwhile cast himself down
in despair, and, resting his head on a stone, fell
asleep. After a while both rose up, the one full
1. That God is wont to give some foretaste of His heavenly joys to beginners in His Service, the better to wean them from earthly pleasures, and to encourage them in seeking His Divine Love, even as a mother attracts her babe to suck by means of honey.
2. That nevertheless it is the same Good God Who sometimes in His Wisdom deprives us of the milk and honey of His consolations, in order that we may learn to eat the dry substantial bread of a vigorous devotion, trained by means of temptations and trials.
3. That sometimes very grievous temptations
arise out of dryness and barrenness, and that
at such times these temptations must be stedfastly resisted, inasmuch as they are not of God;
but the dryness must be patiently endured,
because He sends that to prove us.
4. That we must never grow discouraged amid our inward trials, nor say, like Geoffroy, "I shall never be glad;" but through the darkness we must look for light; and in like manner, in the brightest spiritual sunshine, we must not presume to say, "I shall never be sad." Rather we must remember the saying of the Wise Man, "In the day of prosperity remember the evil." 1 It behoves us to hope amid trials, and to fear in prosperity, and in both circumstances always to be humble.
5. That it is a sovereign remedy to open our grief to some spiritual friend able to assist us.
And, in conclusion, I would observe that here, as everywhere, our Gracious God and our great Enemy are in conflict, for by means of these trials God would bring us to great purity of heart, to an entire renunciation of self-interest in all concerning His Service, and a perfect casting aside of self-seeking; but the Evil One seeks to use our troubles to our discouragement, so as to turn us back to sensual pleasures, and to make us a weariness to ourselves and others, in order to injure true devotion. But if you will give heed to the above instructions you will advance greatly towards perfection amid such interior
S. Francis enjoined his religious to use such moderation in their labours as never to impair the fervour of their minds. And speaking of that great Saint, he was himself once attacked by such deep depression of mind that he could not conceal it; if he sought to associate with his religious he was unable to talk; if lie kept apart he only grew worse; abstinence and maceration of the flesh overwhelmed him, and he found no
From this we should learn that God's greatest servants are liable to such trials, so that less worthy people should not be surprised if they experience the same.